Ask anyone who launches a boat at the end of Ozello Trail what to call the stretch of waterfront next to the county ramp, and they will tell you without hesitating: Pirates Cove. That has been true since before most of them moved here, true through a hurricane, a string of failed redevelopment pitches, and a county vote that rejected a plan to buy the land. So when Citrus County spent this summer asking the public to help pick an official name for the site, the timing struck a lot of residents as strange. The name was never really in question. What was actually up for negotiation is something most people driving past the boat ramp haven't clocked yet.
As The Chronicle reported, commissioners set one requirement when they voted in March to begin the naming process. Whatever the county lands on, the words "Pirates Cove" have to appear in it. Commissioner Jeff Kinnard, who has spent years pushing to get this land into public hands, said as much when the vote passed and again when the public comment period opened. The identity was never going anywhere. What was actually up for grabs was everything that might get attached to it.
The Rule That Already Decided the Argument
Public submissions closed on July 24, and as of this writing the Board of County Commissioners has not yet announced a final name. A volunteer committee made up of Ozello residents and county staff is reviewing what came in before making a recommendation at a future board meeting. But because every valid submission had to include "Pirates Cove," the actual range of outcomes was narrow from the start. Something like Pirates Cove Community Park, or a hyphenated version that credits a donor, was always the likely landing spot.
That narrowness is worth sitting with, because it means the loudest part of this summer's conversation, whether Ozello was about to lose a piece of its identity to a rebrand, was arguing against an outcome the county had already ruled out. Commissioner Janet Barek made this point from the other direction when she cast the lone dissenting vote against even starting the naming process. Her position was that the site was already known, already funded, and already loved under its existing name, and that donor recognition could happen through a plaque or a sign rather than a rewrite. "You wanted Pirates Cove, you went out, you got money for Pirates Cove Park, and that's what it's been," she told her fellow commissioners, as The Chronicle reported.
How Close the County Came to Walking Away Entirely
The naming fight is a mild disagreement compared to what came before it. In 2021, Kinnard brought a plan to the board that would have combined park impact fees, tourist development dollars, and private donations to buy the same 3.6 acres. Commissioners rejected it 3 to 2. Scott Carnahan, who grew up near Ozello, argued the land was worthless for any real development and that the county wasn't in a hurry. The property was valued around $650,000 at the time. Ozello residents showed up anyway. One of them, Barry Schwartz, told commissioners, "We see it every day. We see what a treasure it is," as Florida Politics reported.
The price kept climbing while the county deliberated. By 2025, one local letter to the editor was urging the board to move before the ask hit $1.5 million, warning that the county risked losing the property to a buyer with fewer scruples about the marsh next door. The county finally closed in February 2026 for $1.17 million, a figure built from $900,000 in park impact fees, Tourist Development Council revenue, and leftover Duke Energy special projects funds, with private donations covering the rest. Kinnard stood at the ribbon cutting and called it a permanent part of the Citrus County story. Given how close the deal came to never happening at all, that framing tracks.
The land's own backstory explains why people fought this hard for it. The Mueller family bought the property in December 1957 and ran it as a tavern, restaurant, and small motel, a version of Old Florida that predates the causeway. Before 1963, the only way in was by water. Records from an earlier redevelopment proposal even note that the second floor of an on-site building called Rum Runners operated as a brothel back when the site was still reachable only by boat. Then came March 1993, when an unnamed storm system, one that never got a hurricane name because it wasn't a hurricane, tore through the Gulf Coast and destroyed the restaurant and motel outright. Locals still call it the No-Name Storm. The wreckage sat for years, passed through ownership including a bid to build a condominium resort that county commissioners turned down, before it was finally cleared.
What's Actually on the Table Now
If the base name was locked in from the start, the real decision commissioners still have to make is what rides alongside it. Kinnard has floated a hyphenated format that keeps "Pirates Cove" front and center while acknowledging the Withlacoochee River Electric Cooperative, which contributed $100,000 toward the purchase. He's also mentioned the possibility of handling that recognition through signage or a logo inside the park rather than folding it into the official name at all. Nothing here has been finalized, which is exactly why the committee's recommendation, whenever it lands on a commission agenda, is the meeting worth watching. That's where the actual choice gets made. The public comment period settled the easy part.
The Two Restaurants Already Ozello Doesn't Rename
Nobody in Ozello treats a name change as routine, because the businesses that anchor this community have never needed one. Peck's Old Port Cove sits near the true end of the trail, on a spot that has changed hands more than once without ever changing its name in spirit. Cal Peck bought it from Aunt Myrtle Clifton in the 1980s, a woman who had put a few bar stools in her own house back in the 1940s to serve beer to servicemen from a nearby airstrip. Dan and Diane Williams later ran the restaurant, keeping its blue crab farm going, one of the few operating in the country, along with the soft shell crab pulled straight from that tank. When Hurricane Hermine sent nearly four feet of water into the dining room in 2016, the staff rebuilt the walkways, and the restaurant reopened within the week.
Six miles down the trail, next to the Ozello water tower, Ozello Island Outpost tells a similar story. A sign inside declares the place survived the March 13, 1993 storm, the same one that took out Pirates Cove down the road. Under owners John and Diane Hackney, the Outpost sponsored the Fourth of July parade, hosted potluck suppers, and sold homemade jams from longtime resident Tom Brown on a shelf near the register. Neither restaurant has ever needed a public process to prove it belongs here. The park probably doesn't either, which may be exactly the point residents like Barek were making.
What to Watch For Next
The naming committee's recommendation hasn't hit a commission agenda yet, and there's no confirmed timeline for when it will. The next natural gathering point for the conversation is likely to be the Ozello Civic Association's Craft and Chili Cook-Off, which the association has run every February for more than a decade and a half at its building 6.2 miles down West Ozello Trail. It's the kind of event where fifty vendors, a chili judging table, and a kayak raffle share space with whatever the county is arguing about that year. If the board makes a decision before then, expect it to come up over a bowl of chili whether anyone planned to talk about it or not.
For now, the safest bet for anyone trying to give directions to the boat ramp is the one everyone's been using for almost seventy years. Pirates Cove isn't going anywhere. What gets bolted onto it is still being decided by people who haven't finished arguing yet.
If you're weighing what it means to own property along a stretch of coast this attached to its own history, Trotter Realty knows the Nature Coast well enough to walk you through it. Schedule a consultation.